Opinion 
 Blogs 
 National Comment 
 Ketchup theory will slow economy sharply 

Ketchup theory will slow economy sharply

This is where I stick my neck out. My bet is that the economy is slowing, it will continue slowing, it will slow by at least as much as the Reserve Bank is seeking and probably more.

In short, if our luck runs out we'll slow to the point of recession. If we do reach that point, my bet is the recession will be a severe one.

If I'm anywhere near right, concerns about inflation will soon evaporate, as will the financial markets' expectations of more interest rate rises to come.

The evidence that the economy is already slowing quite sharply is now strong. Retail turnover has shown negligible growth in the first four months of this year.

In trend terms, approvals for the construction of new private dwellings have fallen each month since November. Similarly, the number of loans approved for owner-occupied homes has fallen each month since November.

In the three months to April, the level of business credit grew at an annualised rate of 5 per cent, compared with 25 per cent in the three months to December. National Australia Bank's index of business confidence has been falling for six months, though it recovered a little in May.

I don't normally take much notice of the Westpac-Melbourne Institute index of consumer sentiment - it usually shows short-lived "sticker shock" in response the latest rate rise, but not much else - but it's been falling for months and is now at its lowest level since the post-recession days of 1992.

The slowdown was confirmed by the national accounts for the March quarter, which showed growth in real gross domestic product at an annualised rate of 2.4 per cent.

We can't make much of the 20,000 fall in employment in May - one month can't be called a trend - but falls in the number of job ads suggest rising unemployment isn't far off.

So there's not much room for doubt that the economy's slowing and slowing sharply. But who's to say it won't speed up again in the second half of this year under the influence of the big tax cuts and the huge jump in coal and iron ore prices?

That possibility seems to be concerning the Reserve Bank governor, Glenn Stevens, but I doubt it will happen.

Why not? Because I'm a believer in the ketchup theory of monetary policy. When central banks gradually tighten policy by raising the official interest rate, the dampening effect on demand isn't linear.

For a long time it looks like what you're doing is having no effect - and then one day the dam bursts. You shake and shake the ketchup bottle, none'll come and then a lot'll.

Why does it work like that? Because when you're battling to cool a boom, you're fighting what's politely called "business and consumer confidence", but which Keynes much more revealingly referred to as animal spirits.

And with animal spirits, they're either up or they're down, they're on or they're off. I've seen enough signs in the indicators to convince me the public has switched from go to whoa.

If so, the wariness and caution is more likely to be self-fulfilling than to soon wear off. And a lot of people are so heavily indebted they've got a lot to be cautious about.

What happens to the tax cut? Many people save it - that is, they use it to reduce their debts.

We've been through a protracted period in which many people have been borrowing heavily for housing or consumption. It was always going to be only a matter of time before the pendulum started swinging back.

My guess is that time has arrived, brought on by worries about interest rates, petrol prices, the end of steadily rising house prices and the generally more anxious chat in the media.

So people are pulling in their belts, "repairing their balance sheets" or, in the latest jargon, "deleveraging". They're battening down the hatches in self-fulfilling preparation for stormier times ahead.

As we saw with our highly geared corporate sector in the late 1980s, the trouble with downturns that are preceded by the building up of debt is that they take a lot longer to turn themselves around.

Economic life doesn't return to normal until a lot of the debt has been repaid, but repaying debt during a period of compounding weakness - where overtime disappears, pay rises become sparse and some people suffer periods of unemployment - takes a long time.

Of course, I may prove quite wrong in my forebodings. We'll see.

Ross Gittins is the Sydney Morning Herald's Economics Editor.

Send to a Friend
Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

Comments


There's a growing body of commentators with the same views - Alan Kohler and others at Business Spectator, some of the ComSec people. Starting to get me worried; might be time to start saving harder and keeping an eye on my job security.
Posted by Watcher on 17/06/2008 2:02:33 PM
Your view is persuasive, from a historical point of view. And, yes, the economy is slowing. If you are right, the reduction in consumption spending should bring our imports down to match our exports. And who would have conceived such a balance in an economy such as Australia which has been sucking in investment funds for more than 100 years? Although oil pricing is the immediate concern of many, price signals should stabilize that market at some level. (My guess is around the 1980’s peak (in today’s dollars) of about US$130 per barrel.) However I argue that two unusual factors will cruel your bet. Firstly, the probably unquenchable thirst of China/India for Australian minerals. That income flows into Australia regardless of consumer or business sentiment. Secondly, and more problematic, the escalation in food prices, somewhat driven by increased demand for animal protein by these two countries. With a push from one and a pull from the other, Australia as a whole will continue to battle inflation. One foot in boiling water and one foot in icy water, on average we’ll be right. Already reports of people departing MacKay because of rising rents and of McDonald’s trying to bring migrant labour to WA are coexisting with reports of increased mortgagee defaults in Western Sydney.
Posted by Sean McGinn on 1/07/2008 10:39:09 AM
Hello! Personally I fully agree with recent comments.
Posted by Levitra on 11/07/2008 10:20:31 AM
This is a two tiered economy and is run by mental midgets with a one size fits all interest rate regime that punishes one side into extinction for the other sides corporate windfall... and because they have demand they just raise their prices to pay for any burden... One lever interest rates is crashing the car to save a truck, about time they separated the highway 1. Mining and Government (bounding away) 2. Retail Housing Transport and Industrial economic wasteland The first will track the second in the second half this year.... world parity oil is a sick joke on australians.... world parity with the 3rd world refiners of our 3rd biggest export OIL....(coal1 iron ore 2 OIL 3) vietnam and indonesia are 40c a litre boys with our OIL... wait until the csiro delivers its predicted $8.00 a litre oil ....food and alcohol will triple we wont qualify for the undertakers banana republic because we wont be able to afford bananas either Then the climate tax cult kicks in its dictated imagined statereligion to the pagan greenie god gaia mother earth...pay your tythes $40 a tonne of Co2 and your saved brother praise the Lord carbon disappears just like paying the priests for a imaginary ticket out of purgatory This is a heist a money grab from the top class and its lotus lily the manchurian mandarin designed to collapse or decimate the middle class and broaden the bottom class.... welcome to fuedalism uncoated slavery and bold dictatorship. Australia with over 5% of the worlds earth and using just 2.5% of the worlds carbon is owed either a 2.5% credit or Is entitled to double emmissions and still be carbon neutral $0.00 One biased report from an unelected self declared carbon rattler and nobody gets the same platform to debunk his view... Eat another pie and crack open another tinnie while you watch the footy australia .... Australia a nation of sheep and cattle with lots of dingo's..thats not counting the animals.... about time the sheep get a top set of false teeth
Posted by Mike on 11/07/2008 8:59:28 PM
Maybe we need another kev/watch program; ruddsession.risk@kevin.watch.org.world That way we can watch ruddsession risk go UP the same as; interest.rates@kevin.watch.org.world petrol.prices@kevin.watch.org.world grocery.prices@kevin.watch.org.world unemployment@kevin.watch.org.world rent.prices@kevin.watch.org.world parliemental.pensions@kevin.watch.org.world the more kevin "watches them" the more they go... UP
Posted by Mike on 11/08/2008 1:56:37 PM
I mean when its getting kolder JFK thats Just For Kevin..he thinks its getting warmer and wants to K-tax karbon when weve got tooo many trees...we have 200 billion acres of em 5% of the world with 92% vegetation ...dont watch our trees K no karbon kredits from Kevvie Imagine KeVvie in the Just for Men hair dye ad.. Just For Kevin Oh you its you and urrgh you nailed meee oeooow And then the peeping kevin wants to watch everything to death..interest rates JFK ...housing JFK...economy JFK...sharemarket JFK..fuel baked beans watch them GO the wrong way
Posted by Mike on 13/08/2008 2:10:32 PM
1

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
National Comment
Here is the place for you to vent on any national or world news and lifestyle stories on the YourGuide websites. If there is anything you see or hear that you like or don't like, tell us. Don't keep it to yourself!
Ross Gittins
Ross Gittins

13/08/2008 | Catherine Deveny is no fan of sport. So why is she parked in front of the TV, with bowl of chicken soup in hand?
WA Country Builders
 
Domain.com.au